Why did Randall say that Arthur/Joker tried to buy a gun from him? Edit, It's indicated that Arthur himself never truly believed they were together, that's when we finally know that it had actually only been Arthur fantasizing about her all along.Alternatively, it could be that he was numb from so many traumatic events (beatdowns and tauntings, murdering people, investigation by the police, losing his job, losing/killing his mother, being mocked on national TV, rejection from the Wayne family, not to realize his whole abusive crazy childhood) that realizing Sophie didn't actually know him was just one more rejection and loss piled on. RELATED:Joaquin Phoenix's Joker: 5 Times He Was Sympathetic (And 5 Times He Went Too Far). Also it's possible Arthur may have decided to not bother explaining why he had the gun because he felt (possibly correctly) that nobody would listen to him anyway. Randall represents the elite whereas Garry is a symbol of the lower classes. Its unclear whether or not he kills her and her young child but given we see sirens flashing outside in the following scene, its likely that he killed her. I'm pretty sure they hadn't invented VHS-recorders back then. He wants to shut himself away from the world completely, and the fridge provides a quick and easy way to do just that, but only temporarily.2.) Privacy Policy. Whats truly chilling here is what Joker does throughout it. While some of what he does is understandable, Fleck ends up crossing line after line and, by the time the credits roll at the end, hes a very different man from what he started the blockbuster as. Too tempting to let go.7.) His death or being dead would make more sense to him than his own life of living, OR Arthur took a lot of anti depressant medication, and didn't seem to accept being offered alcohol, like when Randall and Gary came to his apartment with what appeared to be a wine bottle so did Arthur have to avoid alcohol while taking his anti depressant medication? I saw Brett Cullen in this movie as Thomas Wayne and as a character in Dark knight rises. plot-explanation joker Share Improve this question Follow edited Jun 20, 2021 at 15:14 Napoleon Wilson Arthur was lying in bed touching himself when the personnel from the Murray Franklin show called him at home. While she cares about her son, she has shown to lie to him multiple occasions which leads to her downfall. Is this an intentional nod to the Bat Pole? (B) A competent defense lawyer (assuming Arthur could get one) could likely get the first two killings ruled justifiable homicides, but the third man he killed was retreating; pursuing him and finishing him off with malice aforethought as Arthur did is murder in the first degree according to the laws of every state in the USA. Poor Gary wanted to get the hell out of there and couldn't reach the lock and he had to ask Arthur for help. That means people pick on him and when a colleague named Randall gives him a gun because he's his "boy" and he needs to "protect himself." Arthur decides to take him up on the offer. He is presumpting condescending peoples ability to use the term 'cents' as a literate forecoxing of demeneation or banking on somebodies life makes it acceptable that they would even be living in the first place. It might have been a bizarre passing scene to many moviegoers, almost somewhat funny, but that part about Arthur removing the contents of his fridge and hiding inside is poignant. Meanwhile, Murray was doing what he was best at. Arthur's been told his mother is delusional and maybe he doesn't want to accept that and live with that? Archived post. Also notice that the show's director made a "cut" gesture in the background, meaning camera feed was probably cut off and somebody may have at least tried to slip out and find a phone to call the police. Why didn't Arthur respond in shock to Sophie not knowing his name when he was in her apartment? Cloud hosting by Vodien. It's not impossible he just never met her again until he was an adult after she was committed rightfully or not and tried to live back a fantasy. Python script that identifies the country code of a given IP address. Those scenes where Arthur was with his "girlfriend" or up on stage doing stand-up and getting cheered, he walks, talks and reacts in almost "normal" ways. -- One could deduce that Arthur could have fired as few as 3 or 4 rounds, with the actual incident being less dramatic than depicted. Additionally Wall Street is a metaphor or metonym for rich people. The first time he walked down the stairs was after he got fired as a clown and packed his bag. When Arthur and Murray first meet each other, you can see that Murray is very respectful . Sometimes, the episodes may switch between emotional states, resulting in the patient crying uncontrollably before dissolving into fits of laughter. He also shows signs of hallucinations and depression.Previously, this condition was referred to as "hebephrenia." One thing I didn't quite understand in Joker was why Randall betrayed Arthur so quickly when the gun was found. Cookie Notice Why does Arthur kill his mother? He became the Joker. To be absolutely fair, the Arkham case file is more evidence than just the word of a clearly deranged woman. It could've been his imagination, or they could've been laughing AT him and not WITH him but Arthur interpreted it as the audience enjoying his performance. A film about the past of the Joker we see in The Dark Knight (often theorised to have been a veteran, based on some of his actions) would even be great. It's possibly him, but it could be someone who inspired him, or someone who wants to be him, or any number of possibilities. Ultimately, given the sheer volume of Unreliable Narrator going on in this movie, there's no possible way of knowing for sure. Knowing he cant trust a word his mother says, Joker decides to kill her. A little bit like the William Hung experience on "American Idol". But this only serves to bring out the blandness and correctness of Murray Franklin, who as a consummate showman, also pulls off terrible one-liners. (C) Even if his lawyer could arrange some kind of plea-bargain deal to get his sentence for the third killing reduced, Arthur's using a gun he was not legally allowed to own (due to his being mentally ill) would also earn him some further prison time and civil penalties. Edit, There's one possibility that she's always been a genuinely disturbed woman, there's another that she was basically set up by Thomas Wayne to conceal his affair, or possibly even a mixture of the two. Edit, Three possibilities: The whole thing was brilliant, and huge, and like he said to her, When Arthur becomes the Joker and he calls out the horrible state of things in Gotham while on the show with Murray Franklin, Arthur could very well be speaking about present day America where people can no longer seem to communicate civilly. When Arthur confessed to the clerk in the Arkham State Hospital that he killed three people, the first reaction wasn't to call the police. Edit, Without corroborating evidence, such as eye witness reports, security camera footage or the murder weapon itself, it would be difficult to convince a judge to issue a warrant. That whole scene had me on edge for some reason and it was beautifully shot. Perhaps even he wanted to end her suffering? Edit, Bruce Wayne is only a child in this movie and doesn't really play a high-impact part, although Bruce's dad is a big part of the film. A contextual clue that maybe he didn't is later, Fleck didn't murder Gary (Leigh Gill) because the little person was the only clown at his workplace who was nice to him. Also, Todd did not want him in the film, because he wrote the script with Joaquin in mind. The second is that he could not have reloaded the weapon while also carrying his bag in the opposite hand. It's not established Penny's not Arthur/Joker's biological mother and that she ever lied about her relationship with Thomas Wayne. Audiences are tricked into believing Arthur Fleck is in a relationship with Zazie Beetzs Sophie Dumond. The Joker sends death threats pinned to the chest of two corpses whose last names equal the threatened (Harvey Dent). Then he claimed Arthur wanted to buy it. The first scene we see Randall, as he hands Arthur a gun, Randall has an evil smile on his face while suggesting Arthur pays him back sometime, followed up with you know youre my boy. which triggers Arthurs laugh. Edit, No-one.Todd knew, that Joaquin is the perfect role for the Joker. Also whenever Arthur's condition causes him to uncontrollably laugh, in the most inappropriate situations that angers people he didn't mean to offend, with it visibly distressing and physically hurting him. He lives a lonely and tortured existence, suffering from a mental illness that only alienates him further. If you like what you read, follow us on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter and Telegram to get the latest updates. It could just be a Joker.Note that this problem also occurred in the Batman film of 1989, in which the Joker was said to have killed Bruce Wayne's parents, when Bruce was only a child. Viewers have offered several possibilities:1.) Another possibility exists; the movie makes a point of establishing that the city's budget is practically nonexistent and funding for city services has been slashed to the bone. What positional accuracy (ie, arc seconds) is necessary to view Saturn, Uranus, beyond? She made him to believe that he has laughing condition from his birth but the truth was he had a head injury which was made by her boy friend. The Pattinson Batman is more akin to the typical comic book formula. Edit, The steep stairs are connected to Shakespeare and Anderson Avenues at West 167th Street in the Highbridge section of the Bronx, New York City. "You've always been nice to me." Edit, This Joker is a completely standalone non-canon take on the character. Was he too smooth and not awkward enough? Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. If this was the case, it would also explain why Randalls death was the most brutal and drawn out, compared to everyone else. Edit, If you mean the series of films starting with 1989's Batman, that's another timeline. Edit, Even if the victims are rich, police are useless is still a big reason why everything went downhill, and as seen in the subway scene disgrunted citizens don't care if you're a cop they'll rough you up, so they likely need time to get a warrant and convince cops to go in the slums to make an arrest. Even if he throws Randall under the bus how is the boss supposed to believe him when he tries to dodge the fault altogether on instinct because he knew he'll lose the job if he tells the truth. Randall gave the gun to Arthur for money (which he intended to demand from him later). , as well as the fact that Bruce's actor played a young Joaquin in another film. So, the body count question: How many people did the Joker really kill? Like he's laughing to keep from crying, or trying to cry and failing. Just when he thinks he's caught up to them in an alleyway, they smash the sign over his face. On whose turn does the fright from a terror dive end? Edit, It's a direct homage to the film Taxi Driver. Failed comedian turned anarchist murderer, mob boss using the insanity plea, a pure force of chaos and evil- Gotham's dark side personified. Stack Exchange network consists of 181 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. Here's the "joke": Randall was murdered by the patsy he wanted to set up as a murderer. Randall sounds genuinely sympathetic towards Arthur at first, before its discovered its merely a ruse and that he paid the visit to learn what the police know about his firearm. With that in mind we now take a look at the 10 worst things Arthur does throughout the movie to turn him not just into a bad person, but Gotham City's feared Clown Prince of Crime. The movie audience would then go away with a sense that this is what mental illness does to people, without the concept of grandeur or the understanding that this was the origin story of some villain. Did Murray intentionally mean to make fun of Arthur or no? The scene is harrowing as he calmly places a pillow over her face, applying pressure in order to suffocate her. **It's like Ask Science, but all questions and answers are written with answers gleaned from the universe itself. Randall is shown to be so concerned for Arthur's well-being after he gets beaten that he gives him the firearm to defend himself. 3) The name joker ends up being a title that Gotham's craziest, most dangerous and influential criminal takes over; this would allow for a "Jokerverse" where each style of Joker gets his day. This also goes to show Arthur's unstable psyche: He would lie about bringing a real gun to the children's hospital (he told his boss and the detectives it was a prop for his clown act), but he would confess without probing to triple homicide. Nicotine is also an appetite suppressant, so there could be another reason why he smokes so much adding to his frail physique. To make it worse, the mother possibly doesn't even care about this explanation. Does this mean Arthur was prepared to kill anyone who walked through his door? Did Arthur/Joker kill the mental hospital clerk who refused to give him the papers regarding his mother? This shows us that it is not an imagination of Arthur or a misinterpretation but rather that Randall is fully aware of his role in handing the gun over to Arthur.Most of these contacts are also contrasted by Gary. Jonathan "Black Jack" Randall was the key antagonist in the first three seasons of Starz series Outlander. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. | What kind of mental illnesses does Arthur have? Touching kids you dont know and playing with their face? Edit, When Arthur gets his mother's records from the hospital, where it can be seen that she was involuntarily admitted at the age of 25 on November 2, 1952. He was an 18th-century military captain in charge of His Majesty's Eighth Dragoons. What does "up to" mean in "is first up to launch"? Why are they (the three men from the subway) called the Wall Street Three when Gotham is an entirely separate city from New York? He is visited in his apartment by Randall and another former co-worker, a dwarf named Gary (Leigh Gill). And Joker unlocked the door for him and then kissed him on the head. This puts Arthur's birth year in 1948 or 1949, meaning that he was 32-33 years old during the events of the film. He probably knew that he was gonna die either way. It is basically a scene of a child craving for warmth and affection. Did Sophie, who was at best cordial and smiled at Arthur in the elevator, also escape death for being "nice" to him? | Did Thomas Wayne really have an affair with Penny? Does the Joker kill Gambol in The Dark Knight? Edit, An unnamed rioter. Laughing at death is certainly a Joker trait and means that, by the end of the movie, his character is where we expect him to be - both literally and physically. For more information, please see our Worse, he finds out that Penny Fleck allowed one her boyfriends to abuse him. If youve ever wanted to shoot your shot at being an influencer, nows your chance. Brett Cullen and Joaquin Phoenix have an age difference of about 20 years, so this could realistically be true.However, it would imply a large deviation from the comics by making Arthur Bruce's brother. Edit, "comedy is subjective", It is sort of a truism but it does fit, some people like a certain kind of humor that can fall completely flat for others. Arthur and a number of Gotham's lower-class residents certainly seem to think so. While some version of these events may have happened, there's no concrete evidence that they played out in any way like we see in the film, they could just be what Arthur believes / wishes happened. Where Joaquin took it as far as he could with Joker, Heath took it way too far, although that wasn't Heath' fault (he's a method actor afterall) so getting into the Joker was a mentally demeaning task than previously thought possible for both actors involved, Joaquin got a more monitored but mostly freed-freely abled performance as Heath went all out during production AND filming to preserve the persona hIs. I feel kind of silly for saying this but that was an adorable moment in the film. We Are Hiring The ending is a scene before the actual movie. That means people pick on him and when a colleague named Randall gives him a gun because hes his "boy" and he needs to "protect himself." He is obviously very thin, his skeletal appearance is similar to that of a person suffering from anorexia. [CDATA[ He appeared to be trying to show Arthur the error of his ways during the conversation6.) The blas attitude to people dying in the movie. Arthur decides to take him up on the offer. But one aspect can't be argued: It is disturbing and . Arthur wouldn't have so many problems and sloppy miserable fantasies if it was all entirely imagined. Is this an origin story for the Heath Ledger Joker or is this the same Joker from the comics? Or as **fanlore.org** calls it [Watsonian, not a Doylist point of view](http://fanlore.org/wiki/Watsonian_vs._Doylist). Edit, Viewers have offered two opinions1.) In a chat with /Film . At the time, it would not have been unusual to allow Arthur to enter without frisking. To make matters worse, he looked like he was genuinely enjoying himself before they stole his sign, not just faking a good mood for the job. (Laughing previously during his performance instead of doing comedy)The real life late night talk show host David Letterman was known for inviting quirky people onto his show and subtly mocking them, especially if they had low social awarenessHowever many fans prefer to believe that the invitation was real and that Murray's motives were not merely to make fun of Arthur. If Penny abused Arthur and was confined to Arkham, why was Arthur living with her for most of the film, wouldn't he have been separated from her by the state? But there is something a bit off with this scene. Since this movie takes place through Arthur's eyes, and he is shown to be a far from reliable and unbiased observer, however, one might do well to take these opinions with a grain of salt. Very likely. But as a political statement that the victims of oppression and economic destitution in 1980s Gotham City, which is a mirror of New York city, are predominantly black? During his appearance on Franklin's show, Joker tells cruel, unfunny jokes that elicit groans from the audience and a verbal scolding from one of his fellow guests. Edit, You may have noticed that Arthur smoked in a lot of public places, including his SW's office. Another one of his "jokes" (visions/episodes/whathaveyou) was more than likely the killing of the therapist, hence the whacky running back and forth through the hallways with the single bodyguard. Followed by beating him until all he can do is lay on the ground in pain. Joker 2019 movie scene HDFILM DESCRIPTION:Forever alone in a crowd, failed comedian Arthur Fleck seeks connection as he walks the streets of Gotham City. Beginning when Sophie knocks on Arthur's door and is flattered when he confessed he was following her to her place of employment. When Arthur gets assaulted by a group of teenagers, Randall offers him a gun to defend himself, but when Arthur gets fired for possessing the weapon, Randall gives no help to him and demonstrates his true colors and gets killed by the newly turn nihilistic criminal Joker. In his line before the murder, he mentions her full name, and how he has not been happy a minute of his whole life, so the terrible childhood, which maybe now came back to him, is a real factor. At the end of the movie, how exactly was Arthur able to get cigarettes and smoke them in the mental hospital? Edit, Yes, it is possible, but considering how things develop and are revealed through the film this all seems highly unlikely and if it were true, then it would give the viewing audience no clue. Joker is a movie that has taken both the box office and social media by storm, with the disturbing story of Arthur Fleck garnering mixed viewpoints among fans. What was the actual cockpit layout and crew of the Mi-24A? Arthur had his signboard taken from him by a group of teens of colour, who proceeded to beat him up. Overall, Thomas' character is portrayed as a corrupt scumbag, so it is plausible he forged papers to save face. He could've been stalling you can see his producer motioning to him indicating that they called the police.2.) The mother then tells him not to bother her kid (which is sad enough, because he was making the baby happy) and he starts having a laughing fit. This is where we go from feeling sorry for him to seeing him as the psychopath he is. Edit, The film's script clarifies that while his producer tries to end the interview, Murray refuses because he believes that it's making great television and that he may win an Emmy or a Peabody for it. Edit, There is every indication that the whole thing was in Arthur's head. Using an Ohm Meter to test for bonding of a subpanel. While Arthur spares his other former colleague, Gary (who's with Randall when he's murdered), the latter character is presumably killed for his part in getting Arthur fired. Maybe he was he still hung up about the gun. 1) Joker is not a physical threat by that point, simply a supervillain who uses traps, bombs and psychotically loyal goons. In Arthur's mind, he imagines himself as a normal person. Like much else in this movie, whether this is *THE* Joker's origin story or just *A* Joker's origin story is left to the audience to guess. Advertise with us Just tried to build up something that we could relate to in these days and also have something related to the comic book series.Edit: Gotham is based on Chicago and Metropolis (where Superman/Clark Kent lives) is based on New York as per the DC wiki. 2) It's from all the abuse he suffered from his mothers boyfriend when he was younger. He lets fellow clown Gary (Leigh Gill) escape his apartment after Arthur stabs Randall in the eye and bashes his brains in. and our | Edit, He certainly could, but: When she asks what's so funny, he hands her a card explaining he has a condition. Even then Randall takes advantage of the good nature of Arthur by talking him into taking the gun.When things go awry, Randall quickly (and successfully) tries to push the blame on Arthur, which is when Arthur realizes the true colors of Randall.Then later, when the walls are closing in on the gun, Randall makes contact with Arthur again, to ensure that "their stories will align". Edit, Awards Arthur Flecks crimes begin to catch up on him and two GCPD officers try to apprehend him during an action-packed chase scene. We never see him eat, but we do see him feed his mother, and eat nothing himself. Categories It could be that it's someone else's fault Murray got killed because his team didn't up security on the show like they really should have. RELATED:Every Record Joker Has Already Broken. Indirectly and thematically, Arthur set in motion the events that would kill Thomas Wayne, but it is much too indirect for Arthur to have knowingly done so. Was it all in his own head or did it happen and Arthur Fleck is merely incarcerated by the end of the movie? 1 level 2 This is an indictment of American television and the mind-numbing incessant sameness of every day's formulaic show -- a conformity of First Amendment rights to people's sense of propriety. This also reinforces the idea that he's a product of his environment - cold and dark.4.) Others have been quick to point out that he'd have been unable to get out once he climbed inside, so it's certainly plausible. He probably didn't believe Arthur and assumed that he misplaced or broke the sign. There was a super rat scurrying across the side of the building in the bottom-right corner of the scene when Arthur was in the phone booth explaining why he had a gun and then getting fired. Did he imagine killing Randall and letting Gary the midget go? Edit, Script-wise it was an easy way to make Thomas Wayne unlikable. Are those cigarettes real? Edit, Unlikely as his Joker would be too old by the time Bruce grows up and dons the cape and cowl. Edit, Depends on who you ask. And could he have had her committed to Arkham because she refused? So at the end of the movie, was all this Joker stuff all just a dream or a daydream in Arthur's head? You could say it matches the Christopher Nolan trilogy but this film is intended to be on it's own. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. He . (Early eighties, no cell phones.) And that in that case, he made up the story that he's been adopted? External Reviews Some people have asked me, 'Was she killed?' | Edit, The first instance of him staggering is after kicking a trash can. This scene can hit home to anyone who's ever done stand-up comedy and/or got stage fright. Randall was so brilliantly evil that Rolling Stone ranked him 31st in the "40 Greatest TV Villains of All Time" list.

Aventon Aventure Seatpost Size, Articles W