3. If she didnt have a following or fame or anything, would you still disagree with her, or not even give her a second glace.? As good Christians we are to continue to learn and seek the truth, love others, and build Christian Faith in our Lord and Savor Jesus Christ. Since the early 1980s she has researched the Mind-Brain connection and did some of the initial research back in the late 80's showing the neuroplasticity of the brain. At one point when the host of the event was doing a short interview with Dr. It would not cease. I think yours is a jolly good underlying question, though Dr Pitt might not take kindly to its being posed to him by way of your setting him a homework assignment that requires him to write 10 to 20 pages. Doctors call it quackery and the church calls it new age. Eur Rev Med Pharmacol Sci, 2010. I am 40 years old. I think its fair to say that while Dr Leaf draws her conclusions from some scientific documents, there is more than enough research that contradicts her statements and opinions. So, if our brain is not as healthy as it should be, this can directly affect the gut, and thus our digestive system. Toxic thoughts cause depression (Beck& Ellis). Throughout her years of clinical practice, she has helped hundreds of thousands of people learn how to use their mind to detox and grow their brain to succeed in every area of their lives including school, university, and the workplace. The New England journal of medicine 2001 May 3;344(18):1343-50). During her years in clinical practice and her work with thousands of underprivileged teachers and students in her home country of South Africa and in the USA, she developed her theory (called the Geodesic Information Processing theory) of how we think, build memory, and learn, into tools and processes that have transformed the lives of hundreds of thousands of individuals with Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI), Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE), learning disabilities (ADD, ADHD), autism, dementias and mental ill-health issues like anxiety and depression. In her latest blog post, Dr Caroline Leaf attempted to tackle the complex topic of Alzheimer disease. I was under the impression she was an expert in her field of neuroscience which I assumed meant brain mapping and all of the scientific Data to go along with that! I have devoted a whole chapter to breaking down Dr Leafs 98% factoid, showing exactly why its wrong and clearly outlining what real science says, complete with the page number from Dr Leafs book, and the complete list of references. I know whats right. Each communication contains a URL that participants use to gain access to the survey. WebDr. My dad had both, plus Machevelianism. WebSince the early 1980's, Dr. 3. For the benefit of Dr Leafs followers, and for the scientific and Christian community at large, I would appreciate your response. You may argue that she was speaking to a lay audience, and referencing is therefore not necessary. Thanks again for the question, and all the best to you. To me, modern day American Christians seem to be, by far, the most frightened, timid, void- of -peace people groups. In this podcast (episode #477) and blog, I talk to top podcast host and international bestselling author Shawn Stevenson about his incredible healing journey, the mind-brain-body connection, the importance o By Systems, settings, people: Workforce development challenges for the alcohol and other drugs field, 2001: 93-107. Jonathon Cahn I dont know him, but a quick search of the web suggests that hes making a lot of outlandish claims. For 10 years, I have eaten an all organic/homegrown diet. Dr Leaf is not theologically trained I understand your comment was a generalisation, but its a scarecrow fallacy. In terms of a lay audience, I think a bunch of experts getting together and arguing would have all the appeal of watching a session of Parliament. Fowler, G., Evidence-based practice: Tools and techniques. It was advertised as an event that would help us learn to detox the brain. Nat Rev Neurosci, 2009. Dr. Leafs approach is working extremely well for me, and for a number of my friends. This, in turn, increases our cognitive performance, boosting our mental and physical health by positively impacting the way our brain and body functions on a day-to-day basis. Once youre Certified, well help you create an exclusive profile in our directory so clients can find you. The exam will also contain specific open-book questions on the science of the Neurocycle (this will be a multiple choice 90% pass exam that can be completed anytime in the 10 weeks after training). Scientific knowledge will occasionally explain some elements of scriptural knowledge and spiritual truth, but only the how, not the what or the why. She teaches at academic, medical and neuroscience conferences, churches, and to various audiences around the world.Dr. Qualify for an exclusive license to facilitate the Neurocycle method with your clients. I think its good that you wrote to Dr Leaf, even if the outcome was stone-walling from her minions, as predicted. From what I have seen, there isnt the collective will amongst church leaders to listen to what I have to say. Lifestyle a Permanente level. One can only conclude that there is a bi-directional effect between the brain and the stream of thought, which is at odds with Dr Leafs statement that the mind controls the brain and not the other way around. You have to fufill all training requirements to become a certified facilitator, inclduing the final open book exam that has to be completed 9-10 weeks after training. Most TED watchers wouldnt have heard of her before, but Caroline Leaf is a well-known name in western Christendom. If thoughts have any effect on our health, they are artificially magnified by our clean water and sewerage systems. You say, Being a leader doesnt require her to be flawless so we must give her and all leaders grace and room for error. I went to my gynecologist for routine bloodwork because I was feeling exhausted and anxious. I asked if diabetes can be caused by stress and she said, absolutely. However, a lack of standardization across the field and the association of a single frequency with multiple mental health conditions has necessitated more research into the measurement and meaning of each frequency at various levels (Newson & Thiagarajan, 2019). Each communication contains a URL that participants use to gain access to the survey. However, leading mindfulness researchers have called for an instructional tool that not only teaches mindfulness practices, but also covers and assesses mindfulness necessary counterparts: self-regulation and self-management and emotional, cognitive, and behavioral flexibility (resilience). I welcome Pitts questions. Let me be clear I understand the significance of stress on health and the economy, but it is not the cause of 75-98% of all illnesses. Dr. Caroline Leaf There is a strong genetic component of the risk of type 2 diabetes with 62-70% being attributable to genetics [15, 16]. If either of you are incorrect in parts of your teaching or practice I cling to Holy Spirit to lead me into all truth. I am so relieved that God is still in the education system. There are more neurons in the GI tract than anywhere else except the brain. The heart as a mini-brain and the gut as a mini-brain are both figurative expressions. But lets also avoid an unkind legalism that puts unfair burdens on struggling people. HYPERTENSION While part of a much greater mix of variables, genetics are still thought to contribute between 30% and 50% to the risk of developing high blood pressure [17]. In a few months I will be fully trained and stepping into a dream I have had since childhood. It is alarming, first because she had the gall to float such a huge whopper, but on an even more serious note, people believe it. I have not taken antibiotics are any prescriptions medications in over 10 years. QEEG measurements of 11 NeurocycleTM participants were performed before using the NeurocycleTM, after the first 21 days, and after the final 63 days to assess mental health improvements. Teachers were provided with webinars covering the rationale behind and 5-step process of the NeurocycleTM, a tool for mental health detoxing and management. Each of the six factors represents a set of knowledge, attitudes, or behaviors related to self-regulation and control. Key findings from the 2021 State of the U.S. Dr Leafs assertion that 75 to 98% of human illness is thought-related is a clear exaggeration. 12(1): 11-6. It helps get me into that parasympathetic, non-stress state (especially after a super busy day!) Dont buy her books, and warn your friends and your pastors that she is a slick seller of fake science. Nothing she says makes any logical sense. Please, spread the word. its always about the money. She started putting mind over matter thoughts out there to keep him safe, which would keep her in contact with him. That was enough for me. Thanks for your enquiry. But to take a mans theory widely cited in his field of education and psychology and make it seem to lay people its your theory then you better watch out! NEUROCYCLE INSTITUTE 2023 Im sure there are groups of people on-line that also share your eager pursuit of deeper knowledge, where your questions are addressed with the respect due to them. Leaf we have to exercise discernment because they are all human and subject to error. I am aware of research thats studied the anxiolytic properties of Atrial Natriuretic Peptide. This explains the broad role of the amygdala in emotional learning [23] including fear learning. Link to this post: https://cedwardpitt.com/2015/07/22/dr-caroline-leaf-still-contradicted-by-the-latest-evidence-scripture-and-herself/ or to the website debunkingdrleaf.com. Yes, she said this. However, I wonder why your gynaecologist just assumed that your cortisol and diabetes are all related to stress. Mara, D., et al., Sanitation and health. Its like if she uses scientific language and talks really fast that no one will notice. Not for the sake of us, but for others that do not know HIM! In fact, it costs me money to maintain both sites. Caroline Leaf describes her "Science of Thought" process and how she developed tools and processes that help people develop and change their thinking and subsequent behavior. May Jesus bless us all in our sincere attempts to edify the saved and pre-saved!! Critical thinking is needed, to filter out godlessness. Key findings from the 2021 State of the U.S. Have a great day!! Fake science only wins if real science stays silent. Leaf was unable to connect with her son for two hours. (Im assuming that to hold the title of Adjunct Professor, hes published peer-reviewed articles. Hi there!! We are terrified of loosing the faith or our loved ones going to hell. Could I ask about your opinion on people (Christians) other than Dr. This, in turn, impacts the way our body functions by impeding our ability to get nutrients from our food, which can set us up for all sorts of diseases (for more on the gut-brain connection, see my recent blogand podcast). Thank you! OK I am super glad to have stumbled across this information! Scientific knowledge can be discovered through application of the scientific method and critical thinking. The goal of this step is to focus on and embrace what you are inputting into your brain through your mind by gathering awareness of the emotional and physical warning signals, as well as the behaviors and perspectives, you are manifesting. The data collection protocol begins with an email invitation, and non-responders are contacted up to three times by email reminders spaced by 5-7 days each. Eur J Intern Med, 2001. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eYG0ZuTv5rs. So while you may not think Ive been fair, I would argue that I have been more than fair and transparent. In fact, the more you build your brain, the more confident, and less anxious, you will be when faced with a challenge! According to the American Institute of health, it has been estimated that 75 90% of all visits to primary care physicians are for stress related problems (http://www.stress.org/americas.htm). Leaf'steamis not allowed publish theirresearch findings ahead of the peer reviewed journal article, here is some information on theircurrent research projects. Thank you for the comment Dr Branner. I take note of the fascinating subjects and wonder whether the Lord will ever allow me the opportunity to be informed by others capable of guiding me deeper. I would love to research this further as part of my MPH capstone. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2008(1): CD001765. I would greatly appreciate it if anyone can connect me to Dr Leafs formal writings (peer review). No pressure at all. The 21 day brain detox Which you never seemed to get to Then when you finally got there (like a built up crescendo!) In writing my book which critiqued Dr Leafs work, I listed 300 separate citations, and every quote of Dr Leafs was backed up by the book and page number. Dr Pitts own response will probably be much more interesting than mine. He sees, He Knows, HE hears! Int J Biol Sci, 2013. Whatever his credentials, his endorsement means very little, since both Dr Leaf and Dr Amua-Quarshie would know from their experience in research that expert opinion is one of the lowest forms of evidence, second worst only to testimonials [1]. 9. 5. I find her ideas and books dangerous. Riegel, B., et al., State of the science: promoting self-care in persons with heart failure: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association. If Im moving too quickly, Im happy to try and simplify things or direct you to more appropriate resources where I can. Since the early 1980s she has researched the Mind-Brain connection and did some of the initial research back in the late 80's showing the neuroplasticity of the brain. 2010, Basel Switzerland ; New York: Karger. Coincidentally, I was thinking earlier today, in a completely different context, about the possibility that a body of learning and practice that had pseudoscientific foundations, might nevertheless be demonstrated scientifically to be helpful to believers in it, in some cases. Active reach: practice, apply, reteach. Dr. Pitt, could I ask you one small thing? However, leading mindfulness researchers have called for an instructional tool that not only teaches mindfulness practices, but also covers and assesses mindfulness necessary counterparts: self-regulation and self-management and emotional, cognitive, and behavioral flexibility (resilience). I could honestly come up with a book of amazing questions but mine (as with many other practitioners of this theory) would offer a proper diagnostic tool to calculate what you are and give you insight into what practical things this means for you in regards to life! When you gather awareness in this way, you can reconceptualize your thinking. Also, my cortisol came back almost off the charts. This woman is truly a scam artist! As you have heard me say many times before, how we choose to use our brains affects both our mental and physical health. Albeit to discredit everything she writes about. You did qulify your older writing nby adding: In fairness, the fields of neurology and neuroscience are vast and rapidly expanding, and it is impossible for one person to cover all of the literature on every subject. Amen. Did you attempt to collaborate with her and she rejected you? Mr Mac Leaf, the husband of Dr Caroline Leaf, kindly took the time to respond to my series of posts on the teachings of Dr Leaf at Kings Christian Centre, on the Gold Coast, Australia, earlier this month. Thank you for offering that. 63(1): 11-30. Your statement, By your comments it is obvious that you have not kept up to date with the latest Scientific research is an assumption that is somewhat arrogant, and ironic since Dr Leaf is content to use superseded references dating back to 1979 to justify her current hypotheses. NOTE: This is NOT a substitute. Wu, Y.L., et al., Risk factors and primary prevention trials for type 1 diabetes. Leaf we have to exercise discernment because they are all human and subject to error. E-mail us for more info and a custom quote. While Dr. Its clear flame throwing/warring words is going on ~ Strife and quarreling does not please Our Father. Before long, I was into familiar territory, that of the so-called flame war. Dialogues Clin Neurosci, 2011. This leaves little room for freedom in Christ and appreciation of the mystery of our creator. My brother is a narcissistic sociopath Id suggest that no one will gain expertise from listening to myself or Dr Leaf. So does chiropractic. The contract establishes a relationship between yourself and the Neurocycle LLC founded by Dr Caroline Leaf, so that both parties know what is expected. As for whether Dr Leaf is qualified to teach anything its not whether she is qualified or not, its what she is actually teaching that is more important, and if you read through my book and blog posts, I think youll see my position on the quality of her teaching. Dr Leaf extensively references pseudoscience, and even then, misquotes or incorrectly paraphrases it. Sure, medicine and pharmaceuticals are not our saviours, and no one who believes in rational evidence-based medicine would believe that they are. 11. Their mindfulness development and mental health were assessed by the Leaf Mind Management (LMM) scale before and after the program. Rate and comment on Dr Leafs books on Goodreads and Amazon, Google, B&N etc. Can you clarify how attending the same university as Dr Christaan Barnard, or a Nobel laureate, endorses her arguments or precludes her from criticism? Sid just accepted such a bogus statement as fact without batting an eyelid. Also I noticed you have a lot of quotes from Dr Leaf but you dont include the books where you found the quotes or the links to the conferences where you heard her quote. Indeed, at any one moment, we need to look at the context of our life: what we are eating, any medications we are taking, our emotional state is, our work schedule, our thought life and so on. All the best. Is it now 26 years somehow? I think she is just saying that stress takes a toll and us and chronic, long term stress is caused by wrong thinking. I dont say these things to toot my own horn. Analysis of the cohort of children in the Bucharest Early Intervention Project showed that negative affect was the same for both groups. So I sought alternative opinions, on the merits of Dr Leafs new doctrines, or enhancement to old doctrines. Caroline Leaf, Ph.D, BSc, is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist, specializing in cognitive and metacognitive neuropsychology. The researchers conducted face and content validity assessments to ensure a strong initial approach to question selection. This means the vast majority of the worlds population come into this world with genes that should enable the to live a happy and healthy life. However, alarm bells were also ringing regarding her ironclad certainty, and I could see that amongst her followers there could be casualties along the way- eg the person with cancer who strives to be in control of their mind but still sickened. Again, I will discuss this further soon. I also noticed you said above: She may not be a pure tele-evangelist but she is part of their ecosystem. In this final episode of a series with Dr. Caroline Leaf, she illustrates her 5-step process to properly deal with emotional trauma, so you can make it through the difficult times with a healthy perspective. JAMA: the journal of the American Medical Association, 2007. So I guess irritation is in the eye of the beholder. Not only do our choices create real, structural changes in the brain, but they also affect the overall health of our brains, which impacts how the brain and body function on a day-to-day basis, while, if our brains are not healthy, its hard for our minds to be healthy and for us to make healthy decisions. Leaf who move toward raising others in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ! I said, So the stress and my thoughts about the trauma is what caused diabetes? She said, it looks that way. Why had I never given thought to the fact that stress cuases illness? and Doyle, G.A., The CHRNA5-A3-B4 gene cluster in nicotine addiction. One of the many studies that have come out of this research, done by the Buck Institute for Research on Aging, showed dramatic improvement in patients diagnosed with Im not looking for you to respond, but I am looking for you to do some soul searching and ask yourself, why do I disagree with this woman so much? This is something that I have considered scientifically and scripturally and I have discussed it at length and heavily referenced in my book examining Dr Leafs teaching. Its interesting that you feel the need to resort to defence by association, and Ad Hominem dismissal as your primary counter to the points I raised. I couldnt agree more with what youve said! WebDr. I think theres a lot of information out there on epigenetics thats been misrepresented by alternative health practitioners and by people like Dr Leaf, which is best summarised by this paragraph, and indeed, this blog post: In the end, what is most concerning about the hype of epigenetics is how it feeds into what Ive referred to (ironically, of course) as the central dogma of CAM: Namely The Secret. You can also get 20% off your order of BiOptimizers atwww.bioptimizers.com/drleafwith the coupon code: DRLEAF20) to keep my gut-brain connection in perfect health, and my evening cup of organic herbalPiquetea before bed (Get up to 20% off your organic Pique Tea order and FREE shipping atpiquetea.life/drleaf). Caroline Leaf is a communication pathologist and cognitive neuroscientist with a Masters and PhD in Communication Pathology and a BSc Logopaedics, specializing in cognitive and Tell the state or national church oversight for your denomination. Scriptural knowledge can be acquired through systematic study of scripture and the application of critical thinking. He developed the Human Papilloma Virus vaccine and was the 2006 Australian of the Year. Im all in favour of free thinking. He says a staggering 98% of diseases are lifestyle choices and therefore, thinking. Even if its true that Huntingtons, CF etc account for 2% of all illnesses, they account for only a tiny fraction of genetic disease. Prevention of type 2 diabetes mellitus by changes in lifestyle among subjects with impaired glucose tolerance. Sincerely Tracey. CLICK HERE TO REGISTER FOR DR. Google Scholar did not display any articles that had cited it, which must be an error on Googles part. If Dr Leaf had minor errors in her teaching that were still being debated amongst members of the scientific community, then I wouldnt be so worried, because youre right, no ones perfect and were all prone to error. Quantitative Electroencephalography (QEEG) Assessment of the NeurocycleTM. 7. 9(3): e1003284. I try and stay genteel but it would be fair to say that Dr Leaf and I are not exactly on each others Christmas Card list. I was doing research on Dr Leaf when I found this blog post of yours. lol). If this is true, then the brain is pre-wired for both optimism and love, but also fear. However, when I was reading I started questioning when, where and how she was going to reference Mr Gardner and his theory which she was stealing for her own??!! 21. The association between stress and disease is a colossal 85% (Dr Brian Luke Seaward). But again, she fails to reference the quote. He was interested to know about this book and reference to his theory. We live in a society that essentially prevents more than half of our illnesses because of internal plumbing, with additional benefits from vaccination and population screening. John 3:16; Romans 6:23, 12:1-3; Galatians 1-6. You also ask, even (if) she references a 1979 article and may have errors here and there, what is Dr. And I don't have to wait long to start helping people professionally. Gather/input: read, listen, observe. Listen to her voice. We retested and the same thing came back. If you are battling to sleep, take the time to look at where you are in life: how busy you are, what you are eating, and so on, seeing if you can improve your sleeping habits by taking more time to rest, for example, or improving your diet. See that four years after you published your letter to Carolines husband, the same letter and same issues are being batted about. If so, What is it? 9. Hello, you mentioned Dr. 5. Theres no stepping down going on here. I have not had a chance to touch on many, many other points of disagreement. Youre right, most people dont listen, but that doesnt matter. Actually this blog is about the honest truth. I understand how you feel. Information on methods of ridding the physical brain of toxins. 298(14): 1685-7) Negative or toxic thoughts are often the result of an underlying disease process not the cause of it. This to me is a red flag, meaning I have a feeling she didnt say what you claim she said. Your rebuttal is not sound! Holly Wagner? From a nutritional standpoint, it is important to detox the body and get rid of toxins by drinking water, using natural herbs, avoiding processed junk foods, eating lots of fresh, sustainable fruits and vegetables and so on.

Country Club Fairfax Membership Fees, Yoshida Sauce Recipe Pork, Allegheny College Brooks Dining Hall Hours, Western Hills Mall Sold, Articles C